5 Creepy Casino Mysteries Of All Time

Last Updated on October 29, 2024 by Mary

Have you ever heard about stories of mysterious gamblers who vanished into thin air after a winning streak? Casinos appear to hide something behind their flashing lights and glamour. Unsolved crimes and eerie disappearances like out of horror movies.

In this list of 5 creepiest casino mysteries of all time, you’ll explore the shadowy corners of casinos with high-stakes horrors that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Cursed roulette wheels, unsolved mysteries, or winners who were never seen again. What to expect?

Do you dare to read on?

#1 Trevor Angell’s Disappearance

Although not widely known, this case has lots of unsolved mysteries. Trevor Angell was a regular casino visitor in Las Vegas till the story got dark. He simply vanished one night.

According to the story, it all happened in 2000. Trevor was winning big at a casino located off the Las Vegas Strip, known for attracting dubious figures. Witnesses claim he was overly confident. At one moment, he excused himself and headed to the restroom. This is the last time anyone has seen him.

Now, the strange part – the casino’s security footage has gaps, no clear images of him leaving the building, strange phone calls reported by family and friends in weeks following the disappearance, and no traces until today.

Despite the investigations, there are no clues about this case; the bank account was untouched, and his car was left in the parking lot. Among conspiracy theories – mob involvement, eerie explanations, or staging his own disappearance.

#2 Murder of Casino Owner Ted Binion

Ted Binion was a known casino owner in Las Vegas. His mysterious death in 1998 involved lots of twists and allegations of betrayal or drugs. He was found dead in his home, leading investigators to think he might have overdosed. But the suspicion grew out of many reasons, such as stashing silver, worth millions, in his underground vault. Why would he do that?

One of the suspicious discoveries was that his vault was raided shortly after. Was it a drug overdose or a forced overdose? Suspicion fell on his girlfriend and her alleged lover, who was found digging up the silver two days later. They both were convicted of murder, but the conviction was overturned a few years later since there wasn’t sufficient evidence.

This mysterious story remains one of the most sensational in Las Vegas, with lots of questions about what truly happened.

#3 The Circus Circus Casino Disappearance

Another creepy story of a mysterious vanish in one of the Las Vegas casinos. One of the strangest disappearances happened in 1997. Margarita Arguello was a 54-year-old grandmother visiting the Circus Circus Hotel Casino.

On the night of her disappearance, she was last seen when playing slots and speaking to casino patrons. Similar to the first mystery, Margarita left to use the restroom but didn’t return. The casino footage system caught her walking within the casino premises, but nothing suspicious.

Even if the police searched the casino territory, they didn’t manage to find anything. That’s what raised multiple theories – possible surveillance footage issues or foul play, human trafficking, or abduction. All her belongings were untouched, and there was no sign of any struggle. The fact is that the camera didn’t catch her leaving the casino, raising more questions.

Despite investigations, this case remains one of the most mysterious, unsolved disappearances. It is often cited in discussions about security at casinos, reminding visitors that people can vanish even in highly popular environments.

#4 The Flamingo Hotel Ghost Stories

It seems most of the stories happened in the most popular gambling location – Las Vegas.

The Flamingo Hotel and Casino is one of the most renowned establishments in the region. It was opened in 1946 by the mobster Bugsy Siegel. Besides being a glamorous resort, this casino is also known as a source of several ghost stories linked to its founder.

The casino founder was murdered in Beverly Hills in 1947, far from Las Vegas. The hotel staff and guests have reported creepy encounters like strange noises or flickering lights. Some claim to have seen a ghostly figure. According to them, Bugsy’s ghost haunts the casino that he was overseeing when in construction.

The most reported sighting is near the outdoor garden. Staff and guests claimed to have seen a shadowy figure near the fountain or the garden. The Flamingo’s pool is another place with frequently reported ghost sightings.

In addition, staff has reported other creepy occurrences as well, such as slot machines acting strange, strange sounds, footsteps, or shadows. The casino is filled with mysterious tales that intrigue visitors.

#5 The Disappearance of George Jay Vandersloot

This story took place in 1995, but the place is the same as with most casino mysteries – Las Vegas. Vandersloot was a 53-year-old businessman who disappeared without any trace during his trip to Las Vegas. He was known for being cautious in both his professional and personal matters.

He was on a routine trip. After checking into his hotel and visiting casinos, he vanished. He was last seen at the Maxim Hotel and Casino, which is no longer working. According to witnesses, he told his friends that he would return to his hotel but was never seen after. Concern grew when he didn’t show up to a meeting and didn’t contact family. He was reported missing.

Compared to other cases, this revealed a few clues. His car was found at the airport days after, but there is no record of him leaving Las Vegas. His personal belongings were left untouched in his room. Credit cards and bank accounts showed no unusual activity. Among popular theories – foul play, human trafficking, or voluntary disappearance.

Despite extensive investigations, there are no answers. Similar to other cases, this casino mystery remains unsolved, revealing the dangers and dark sides of the gambling field, far from the glamour and glitz of lavish resorts. These are a few of the creepiest casino mysteries that raise several conspiracy theories about casinos.